The CW Source

Supernatural rules, OTH sucks...'nuff said.

Cue Kansas: "Carry On my Wayward Soooooooooooon!"

one tree hill should win supernatural is stupid

yes! to supernatural: A WELL DESERVED WIN!!

for real. people who think they are cheating need to watch this clip. sam and dean kicked major ass

Sam vs. Dean...
Because they kick a**!
PS
To those people who doesn't appreciate SPN winning I'm sorry but if your fave doesn't win then maybe you should vote for them more often.

brooke's fight! i don't watch supernatural and although i love gossip girl and 90210, those fights were kind of lame.

I voted Sam/Dean. Brooke's attack was a good plot twist especially given who it turned out had a hand in making it come about but Sam/Dean was less about being attacked by the unknown and more about being attacked by the only person you trust in the world. It was clear the emotion in the Sam/Dean fight was less about fear like the Brooke/jack's bro attack and more about a reckoning between the brothers. That's always more compelling than just a random attack.

Brooke was so amazing in that scene !

SAM AND DEAN THAT SCENE WHEN THEY WERE FIGHTING JUST BROKE MY HEART, I WAS YELLING AT MY TV AND EVERYTHING!! (ALSO LOST MY VOICE) BUT SAM&DEAN FTW!!

As much as I love One Tree Hill, I can't stand the character Brooke at all, so she most definitely doesn't get my vote. I voted for Dean and Sam.

OMGSH the supernatural fight scene was the best! i had been hoping for something like this to happen, except the moment they started fighting, i couldnt stand to watch it. my heart literally broke into pieces, especially when dean's face collided with the glass.

Supernatural just has to win this one hands down. The heartbreak Sam and Dean's fight evoked was second to none and the fight itself was as realistic as it gets between two fantastic actors.
Supernatural to win this one, no doubt.

I am a HUGE Brooke/OTH fan, but I had to go with Dean/Sam fight. That scene broke my heart into pieces.

nothing can beat Sam and Dean! >.< Supernatural FOREVER!

What you see when Sam and Dean are fighting is the real thing! Well, sort of. As everybody knows, Jensen and Jared are the best of buddies, but they do most of their own stunts. And NOBODY does them better!

Sam vs. Dean FTW!!! Although really broke my heart to see their bond shatter right in front of my eyes. But best fight scene out of them all. Supernatural is awesome!!!!

Sam and Dean, without question. That fight was absolutely brutal, no hold barred. It represented such unfathomable emotional pain, and then Sam strangling his brother, simply because he could. Too bad the clip cut off before Dean delivered the line, "If you walk out that door, don't you ever come back," just like his father had said before him. Caustic emotional pain.

I definately voted for Supernatural. - The rest, 'cept 4 the OTH one, sucked ..... no offense.
I'm a devoted Supernatural fan, and as a plus for this conpetition, this shows just how much Sam and Dean know - as in hopw to protect themselves and defend themselves - I mean; 70% to 26%, 3% and 1%?!
That really makes me happy for Supernatural, even though i'm not too happy for Sam and Dean about that fight. )^`:>

Sam and Dean fight definately! I waited for it all season and when it finally came I just about died!! It was so intense and so amazing.. I have no words to describe how it moved me! Brooke was awesome and I'm an OTH fan as well but SPN is my fave and I'm voting for them!!

Brooke kick Ass! I love the Scene. She was totally awesome and strong and i totally trust in her to keep my home safe now. hehe X]

What ever happened to Jason C? [2]

Ok, first off. Serena vs. Blair was comical. Navid and Ty seem to be rolling around more than actually fighting.
It comes down to OTH and SN.

Brooke fighting off the guy was great. It showed how strong she had become. I especially loved she was doing this because of what he had done to Sam, not for the attack on her. But I looked forward to this fight for such a long time that when it did happen, it seemed really anti-climatic.

Sam vs. Dean, on the other hand was what we were preparing for all season long. And it meant a lot of things mainly, the ending of the bond that drove the show. It was more than what I had expected it to ever be. So I had to give it to them.

I love Supernatural *----*

supernatural fight obviously

one tree hill's fight was pretty good but when brooke was struggling near the end, it looked like the guy kinda just let her get to her purse. and when someone just pulls a gun out like that, there's a really big chance the gun has its safety trigger on. that guy's an idiot for not taking that chance.

jared and jensen were the best! here they showed the skill and technique needed to be a hunter (sadly used against each other) and it's not random kicks and punches that you just throw whenever you get the chance. there was a lot of blocking too! that's what i love about their attacks. they know when to throw a punch, dodge, or block.

but both supernatural and oth were pretty intense scenes. brooke struggling with the guy that attacked her - sam and dean final confrontation

i still think the video clip should've included dean saying 'if you walk out that door, dont you ever come back.' that was an amazing scene and omg my heart broke when i watched it.

on another note...
gossip girl scene was just blah. the motives were just sad. serena shouldn't play around with applying to a college even though it doesn't interest her, just to get back at a friend. blair shouldn't take it like if serena is out, she's in. there are many other applicants to yale.
the fight - ugh catfight that was kinda just pathetic

I really don't know who to vote for... OTH or SPN. Both scenes broke my heart and brought out so much emotion for me. Ahh! My two favorite characters Brooke and Dean!

I'm going to have to vote for Brooke though. That whole episode was amazing and was the turn around for OTH S6. Everything prior to that eppy in the season sucked.

If the Sam vs Dean fight wouldn't be so awesome I would vote for the OTH fight, that girl is awesome!

i think we need to get Sophia Bush over to the Supernatural set so she can kick butt with both Sam and Dean, and this way the next Sourcie fight scene will be a no brainer! ;)

I'm going for Brooke's fight scene, because, even though i'm a devoted SPN fan, the boys fight scene broke my heart...I don't want them to win for fighting eachother! Besides, Sophia owned in that scene =]

What ever happened to Jason C?

T.T. don't go hating the Supernatural fans for loving their show.
I know very little about OTH but I think Brooke's fight comes in a very close second to Sam/Dean. I'm all for the Brooke standing up for herself and defending herself. It looks like it was a great scene. But you have to understand that the Sam/Dean fight wasn't just a fight either. There's meaning behind it that people who don't watch the show wouldn't understand. This is the mother of all fights b/c it was the breaking point of the brother's relationship that has been so strong since day one. You may have "jumping up and down due to all the excitement" when Brooke pulled her gun, but every Supernatural fan's heart broke into pieces that day.
Plus, you can’t deny that Jared and Jenson displayed the best fighting ability out of all the candidates.

Well I'm voting for the Sam and Dean fight because, even though it was painful to watch, it was an amazing scene!

I just really hope people don't come complaining when Supernatural wins this one too... It's one of the best scenes of the whole season!

Imo, after watching those clips no one should be yapping like a child how unfair Supernatural's success in The Sourcies is. Sam vs. Dean really was the best fight, the only fight where the fighters seemed to know what they were doing. That's entertaining. Thank God the show's got Jared and Jensen.

Sam and Dean, 4 sure. Can we say EPIC??? :)

Love from Portugal

SPN 4 ever

i liked them all... but the one tree hill on was the best i think.

O come on supernatural geeks
this should obviously go to brookes fight with her attacker
when she pulled out her gun i was jumping up and down due to all the excitement
give me a break!

Sam Vs. Dean